Alternative IPOs Still in Demand

A panel at Thursday’s 2012 SEC Government-Business Forum on Small Business Capital Formation that discussed issues not addressed by The JOBS Act included a look at the state of alternative IPOs by John Borer, senior managing director and head of investment banking for New York-based Benchmark Co. By his reckoning, they’re alive and well. And preferable. “If you can get big underwriters to do your IPO for you, go do it,” he said. “But the statistics were 2,000 IPOs (completed each) year 15 years ago.

Equity Line and ATM Promoters Eye Same Niche

The growing appeal of at-the-market offerings among emerging growth companies has introduced more competition into the micro cap financing market, particularly for investors and banks that provide structured equity lines – a segment of the market that already is highly combative. But while emerging growth companies have pared the number of equity line agreements they’re inking, the structure continues to appeal to a substantial number of issuers that need cash and that often have few other options. In some cases, ATMs have failed to live up to their billing. “It has been a little bit challenging – there certainly has been competition created by the ATM structure,” said Jason Cohen, a representative with Westlake Village, Calif.-based Financial West Group, which has facilitated five equity line deals with commitments totaling $125 million this year. “But we have found that people have had variable results with that structure and are dissatisfied because they haven’t been able to piece together capital in any predictable pattern.”

To a large degree, ATMs and equity lines provide issuers with the same benefits: They generally allow companies to raise equity in the amount and at the time of their choosing without extensive pre-deal marketing or other sales efforts.

Terrapin

Spun Fund Keeps Equity Line Focus

Acqua Wellington Asset Management, for years an active equity line provider to small cap companies, has spun out its Terrapin Opportunity Fund amid a decision to get out of the business, a source close to the situation said. Rob Schacter, the former president of equity line placement agent Reedland Capital Partners, and Acqua Wellington officials will oversee the fund, the person said. Over the last 12 years Acqua Wellington funneled $228 million to issuers in 66 transactions, according to PlacementTracker, a unit of Sagient Research. It made a total commitment of $3.7 billion in those deals. Acqua Wellington’s phones in its New York headquarters were out of service Thursday.

BDC Offers Capital to Issuers, Opportunity to Investors

In an era when smaller companies find it harder than ever to reach the IPO stage, Keating Capital's (KIPO) development company (BDC) provides funds for companies on the way to going public while giving an investors a chance to buy into companies while they are still private. At the same time, Keating Investments negotiates for "structural protection" that allows the fund to soften the blow when an issuer's IPO is not as robust as planned. The fund allows retail investors an opportunity to purchase hot pre-IPO companies, but not when they are so hot as to burn investors. Keating Capital founder Tim Keating told Growth Capital Investor that the venture capital industry harbors unrealistic views of the prospects of many companies it sponsors. "In Silicon Valley, there is a silent conspiracy of optimism with respect to revenue and earnings projections," Keating said.